Five European Union countries are pressing ahead with plans to establish a migrant return centre in Rwanda, reviving a contentious approach to immigration control that previously encountered major legal obstacles in the United Kingdom.
Germany, Austria, Denmark, Greece and the Netherlands confirmed on November 16 that they were negotiating with Kigali to establish a facility for people whose asylum applications have been rejected and who cannot be returned to their countries of origin. The first transfers could begin in 2027.
But Human Rights Watch has challenged the proposal, arguing that Rwanda’s human rights record makes it an unsuitable destination and that European governments risk undermining their own international obligations.
In an exclusive interview with Radio Agasaro Kaburaga and The African Gazette, Lewis Mudge, Human Rights Watch’s Central Africa Director, questioned both the humanitarian justification and the practical effectiveness of the proposed arrangement.
“These agreements show a willingness on the part of these EU countries to overlook human rights principles simply in pursuit of migration control,” Mudge said.
He argued that transferring rejected asylum seekers outside Europe would not resolve the underlying weaknesses of European migration systems.
“It does nothing at all to actually address the flaws in the EU system’s migration policy,” he added.
A new European migration initiative
The five European governments announced their plans during migration discussions in Vienna, alongside Rwanda’s Interior Minister Vincent Biruta.
The proposed facility, described as a “return hub”, would initially accommodate approximately 100 people at a time. It would primarily receive adults who have exhausted legal avenues to remain in Europe but cannot be returned directly to their countries of nationality.
According to the governments involved, the arrangement would provide opportunities for integration into Rwandan society or eventual voluntary return to countries of origin.
European officials maintain that the initiative would help discourage irregular migration, reduce pressure on national immigration systems and weaken people-smuggling networks.
The proposed centre differs from the UK’s abandoned Rwanda arrangement, which was designed to transfer certain asylum seekers before their claims had been determined. Under the new European proposal, the people transferred would already have received final decisions rejecting their applications.
Nevertheless, questions remain about how the facility would operate, how long migrants would stay, what protections they would receive and how the participating governments would finance the arrangement.
Mudge questioned whether a facility of such limited capacity could have any significant effect on European migration pressures.
“Rwanda does not have the capacity to absorb hundreds of thousands of people,” he said.
He described the initiative as largely symbolic, arguing that the number of people transferred would be too small to resolve the difficulties European governments face in returning rejected asylum seekers.
Rwanda’s human rights record under scrutiny
Much of Human Rights Watch’s opposition centres on its longstanding concerns about political freedoms, detention practices and the treatment of government critics in Rwanda.
During the interview, Mudge referred to alleged interference with the judiciary, suspicious deaths of government critics and restrictions affecting journalists, civil society organisations and political opponents.
He also questioned whether independent organisations would be able to monitor the treatment of migrants transferred from Europe.
“This is a country where no human rights organisations can work freely,” he said, referring to the expulsion of several human rights researchers.
For Mudge, the absence of effective independent scrutiny raises doubts about the assurances European governments might obtain from Kigali.
He pointed to the Universal Periodic Review process at the United Nations, during which several European governments involved in the proposed arrangement had themselves raised concerns about Rwanda’s human rights situation.
Mudge accused those governments of inconsistency in their approach to Kigali.
Rwanda has repeatedly rejected allegations of systematic human rights abuses and maintains that it provides a secure environment for refugees and other migrants.
The government also points to its experience hosting refugees from neighbouring countries and participating in international humanitarian arrangements.
Mudge acknowledged that some migrants transferred to Rwanda under internationally supervised programmes may have experienced relatively favourable conditions.
He cited arrangements involving people evacuated from Libya, where international organisations have provided oversight.
However, he argued that such examples do not eliminate concerns about the treatment of other vulnerable groups.
“Whilst some refugees may have a good experience, overall, you cannot say this is a rights-respecting nation,” he said.
Lessons from the British and Israeli agreements
The European proposal also raises questions about earlier attempts to establish migration partnerships with Rwanda.
In November 2023, the UK Supreme Court ruled that Britain’s asylum transfer arrangement with Rwanda was unlawful, citing concerns about the risk of people being returned to countries where they could face persecution.
The British government then tried to address those concerns through additional legislation and diplomatic guarantees, but abandoned the scheme after a change of government in July 2024.
Mudge said the British experience demonstrated the difficulty of relying on assurances without effective safeguards.
He also referred to an earlier arrangement between Israel and Rwanda involving Eritrean and Sudanese asylum seekers.
“We’re still trying to establish what happened to some of those Eritreans who were sent to Rwanda,” he said.
Human Rights Watch has documented concerns about the treatment and onward movement of migrants transferred under previous arrangements.
The European governments involved in the latest initiative insist that their proposal will comply with international human rights standards.
Whether those assurances will satisfy legal scrutiny remains an important question as negotiations continue.
Could European funding affect the Congo conflict?
One of the interview’s most significant exchanges concerned the potential financial and political implications of a migration agreement for the conflict in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo.
Human Rights Watch has repeatedly accused Rwanda of providing military support to the M23 armed group, which has been involved in fighting against Congolese government forces.
Rwanda has denied supporting M23, while accusing the Congolese authorities of failing to address security threats along their shared border.
Asked whether European funding for a migration centre could indirectly support Rwanda’s military activities, Mudge expressed concern about payments made directly to the Rwandan government.
“When a deal like this is made, especially a bilateral deal with several countries in which there are direct payments made, the state has the right and the capacity to use those funds as it sees fit,” he said.
He argued that the wider implications of providing financial support to Kigali should not be overlooked.
“Whether this EU money will directly go to the Congo is not as important as recognising that the EU money goes into the coffers of a government involved in the conflict, he said.
His comments reflect a concern about the indirect budgetary effects of international payments rather than evidence that money from the proposed arrangement has already financed military operations.
No final funding agreement has been announced, and no evidence has been established that payments under the proposed European scheme have been diverted to military activities.
For Mudge, however, the political implications extend beyond financial transfers.
He suggested that concluding a new migration partnership with Rwanda could weaken European governments’ credibility when addressing alleged abuses in eastern Congo.
Calls for independent assessments and safeguards
Despite his opposition to the proposed arrangement, Mudge acknowledged the difficulties European governments face when rejected asylum seekers cannot be returned to their countries of origin.
He said these challenges should not excuse governments from carrying out thorough human rights assessments before negotiating agreements with third countries.
“At a bare minimum, there should be a meaningful and public human rights feasibility assessment,” he said.
Mudge also called for explicit provisions protecting fundamental rights and mechanisms capable of ensuring that such commitments are respected.
He referred to findings by Human Rights Watch, United Nations mechanisms and Amnesty International concerning torture, ill-treatment and arbitrary detention in Rwanda.
“There should be a meaningful effort to guarantee a respect for basic human rights in any of these types of agreements,” he said.
He added that Human Rights Watch had not yet seen sufficient guarantees in the proposed European arrangements.
The five European governments say their initiative will operate within applicable national, European and international legal frameworks. Rwanda has presented the discussions as an opportunity for international cooperation on migration management.
With negotiations expected to continue ahead of a possible launch in 2027, the debate is likely to focus on whether the participating countries can establish credible safeguards, independent monitoring and legal remedies for those transferred.
For Human Rights Watch, the fundamental question remains whether European governments can meet their obligations to protect migrants while transferring responsibility for their future to a country thousands of kilometres away.
Listen to the full interview with Lewis Mudge, Human Rights Watch’s Central Africa Director
Mr Mudge speaks to Radio Agasaro Kaburaga and The African Gazette about the proposed EU–Rwanda return hub, refugee protections and the conflict in eastern DR Congo.


